The acquittal of Asia Bibi, a Christian woman accused of blasphemy, and three days of protests after have exposed long-running fault lines in Pakistani society. Here's a look at how it played out on Pakistani social media.
Pakistan's apex court acquitted Asia Bibi, a Christian woman who was sentenced to death in 2010 on blasphemy charges, in a landmark ruling announced on October 30, that ignited protests by hardline religious groups, predominantly the Tehreek-i-Labbaik Pakistan (TLP), in several cities across the country.
They have taken off ...! #AsiaBibiAcquitted #TLP pic.twitter.com/vysix3QMDE— ali r basit (@sardaralirbasit) October 31, 2018
During the course of the protests and amid the images of destruction and mayhem, the suffering of ordinary people also came to light.
These TLP Goons have Blocked the Motorway too.— Moin™ ✨ ✪ (@iMoinTweets) November 1, 2018
Pic : Mother strangled on Motorway.#TLP #Protests #AsiaBibi pic.twitter.com/MJdL9Tv9Up
These included a video of child, who was selling bananas, getting stuck in the midst of charged protestors who eventually made off with all the produce he had to offer.
Meanwhile they looted this little kid, yet another painful side of protests across Pakistan. O Allah please help us.#Protest #Pakistan #AsiaBibi #AsiaBibiVerdict #AsiaBibiCase #LawAndOrder #ISPR @ImranKhanPTI #JummahMubarak #يوم_الجمعه pic.twitter.com/Gjc5jIMazc— Muhammad Yousuf (@MYousufSoomro) November 2, 2018
In another disturbing video, a small group of children are seen tying a noose around a doll's neck and dangling the toy while chanting slogans associated with the TLP.
Even #Nazis did not brainwash their children like this 👇— Dr. Asim Yousafzai (@asimusafzai) November 4, 2018
Middle class kids are hanging #AsiaBibi figurine from a bike with #TLP flag and chanting #Labbaik. pic.twitter.com/GrhtSgooXx
Earlier on October 8, the Supreme Court of Pakistan reserved its judgment after deciding on Bibi's 2014 appeal against the 2010 death sentence handed to her.
The Tehreek-i-Labbaik (TLP) had threatened to protest and take to the streets if the Supreme Court verdict was issued in favour of Asia Bibi.
Panaflexes installed by #TLP with #English text in #Lahore with a warning apparently to #SupremeCourt dat #blasphemy convict #AsiaBibi could be killed by public if acquitted. pic.twitter.com/6AmcGG7ZWB— Wajih Ahmad Sheikh (@wajihsheikh) October 19, 2018
Many people were delighted by the verdict that set free a woman who had been falsely accused and had already served eight years in prison.
Landmark judgement by Supreme Court to acquit #AasiaBibi today.False accusers took half her life away. Now the state must protect all those who stand for the rule of law and justice.We have all been witness to the havoc mobs have wreaked to red lines before.That line must be held— SenatorSherryRehman (@sherryrehman) October 31, 2018
Congratulations to the entire Taseer family. #SalmanTaseer would have been a happy man today knowing #AasiaBibi has been released. #Voice4Oppressed How frightening are those who are closing down cities because the law did not comply with their demands. Now Stay strong Pakistan🙏 pic.twitter.com/C7ysca2r4P— Nadia Jamil (@NJLahori) October 31, 2018
But many others, mostly TLP supporters, began to stage protests in major cities of Pakistan immediately after Asia Bibi's acquittal was announced on October 30, which only intensified in the days to come.
#TLP protest in front of #Punjab Assembly against #AasiaBibi verdict#Pakistan pic.twitter.com/RnCCTosM0h— Gohar Mehsud (@tribaljournlist) October 31, 2018
.@ImranKhanPTI sb... here is another video made on October 31 in which #TLP activists breaking police vehicle in Punjab Assembly chowk. #Aasiabibi pic.twitter.com/MfyCFmRTwg— Shahid Hussain (@journalistlhr) November 3, 2018
The TLP leaders also issued an edict calling for the three judges, who had ruled in Asia Bibi's acquittal, to be killed.
Contempt of court?? He issued Fatwa to kill #Judges. What a shame!! Don't remain silent. Let's erase this cancer forever. #hangethem #traitors #AasiaBibi #SupremeCourt #KhadimRizvi #AfzalQadri pic.twitter.com/B5FO6jc5d7— Umair Mushtaq (@UmairMushtaq7) October 31, 2018
The leaders of the religious party also called for a mutiny within the army, and specifically against the Army Chief General Qamar Jawed Bajwa, and urged his followers to topple Imran Khan's government.
Listen what #TLP leadership has to say about on duty COAS pic.twitter.com/H0arzJpMpU— Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang (@clockend90) October 31, 2018
As the protests turned violent, many people began to question the inaction of law enforcement personnel and the absence of the writ of the state.
Around the same time Prime Minister Imran Khan, who also holds the federal interior ministry, left the country on a three-day visit to Beijing.
#Islamabad “What steps have been taken to maintain law and order, to protect our Judges, to protect #AasiaBibi? There is no one here today to answer our questions.”— Sobia Ali PPP (@SobiaAliPPP) November 1, 2018
- Chairman Pakistan Peoples Party @BBhuttoZardari pic.twitter.com/qk0YgyLPTi
Don't cover them— jasraali (@jasraali) October 31, 2018
Don't empower them.
Don't embolden them
They are parading hate, inciting murder of the country's top judges and bending over backwards to kill an innocent mother. #AasiaBibi pic.twitter.com/ujWG4iFguG
Is this the way Rangers normally treat protesters? Asking for a friend#AasiaBibi pic.twitter.com/q1Rr00s5x1— Shahjahan Khurram (@91Shahji) October 31, 2018
A bus tried to cross barriers of #TLP protestors, the TLP workers open fire on passengers one dead— قاضی محمد جلال الدین (@JalalQazi) November 1, 2018
This is alarming, where is state ? pic.twitter.com/kePNM1raZ1
A few people were killed and several others wounded during the protests, according to social media reports, which could not be independently verified.
A driver tried to cross his bus through barriers of #TLP protestors in Rawalpindi, TLP workers opened fires on passengers, one dead at the occasion — Islam is religion of peace, killing anyone is unbearable. Why #PMselect's #PuppetGovt not taking action?pic.twitter.com/LoTzcXlQKd pic.twitter.com/HXWYm426HR— Abdul Majid Kalwar (@Majid_PSF) November 1, 2018
BREAKING NEWS:#TLP protesters attack Shia Procession near Sindhi Hotel in #Karachi. 1 dead, 9 injured. #Pakistan #AsiaBibi #AasiaBibi pic.twitter.com/P0zqPtz81L— علی جاوید (@AliJaved24) October 31, 2018
Protesters attacked Bhashani Sweets in Pakistan Bazar area, 2 people injured. This is pathetic.#Karachi #TimesOfKarachi #KhiAlerts #protest #AsiaBibi #SupremeCourt #ImranKhan #TLP pic.twitter.com/WdUy7mUr8c— The Times of Karachi (@TOKCityOfLights) November 1, 2018
#Karachi: Funeral of two #TLP workers offered near Sindhi Hotel, #NewKarachi. Heavy deployment of Police & Rangers. #KHIAlerts pic.twitter.com/SysLPmXh4R— SherY - (@SherySyed_) November 1, 2018
Some citizens were taken aback by the coverage of the protests on local media who had, once again, downplayed the TLP demonstrations. The country's media regulator urged media organisations to tone down their coverage so as to not further inflame the situation. Social media, thus, took the lead in providing coverage of the events.
#ملاگردی_بند_کرو #protest— Sara Pirzada (@Sara_Pirzada) November 1, 2018
Received this on WhatsApp as a forward message. I’m shocked that the media isn’t reporting any of this! They’re telling everyone that the situation is calm.
But it’s clearly not! #IslamicTeachings #KhadimHussainRizvi #TLP #ImranKhanPrimeMinister pic.twitter.com/yTNqKz99vV
While people who were against Asia Bibi's acquittal were expressing themselves by taking to the streets, people in favour of the Supreme Court verdict mostly expressed themselves by condemning the protests.
Ferozepur road Lahore.#AasiaBibi #Lahore #Roads #Strike pic.twitter.com/y02aA9BdxY— سرجکل سٹرایک (@IRO_Pakistan) October 31, 2018
These guys are angry because a poor Christian mother has been freed after nine years of solitary confinement because the blasphemy charges against her were not proven. It would have been hilarious had it not been so sinister. #AasiaBibi pic.twitter.com/uL1ged78KN— Ammara Ahmad (@ammarawrites) November 1, 2018
#TLP's psycho miscreants beating Kafir bikes before torching them !#AasiaBibi pic.twitter.com/UIJ1NCBjO3— Reasoner (@PakiReasoner) November 1, 2018
Somewhere b/w Gustakh e Rashool and Ashiq e Rasool we have lost Islam. Everyone wants to die and kill in the name of Islam and Prophet(pbuh) but not live on the principles of Islam and Sunnah of Holy Prophet(pbuh).— M. (@mad_malang) November 1, 2018
This is an alarming situation#AasiaBibi #TLP pic.twitter.com/1vm6XslXAg
The PTI-TLP connection?
Some people chose to give the governing Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf a reminder of their own past actions and policies when the Imran Khan-led party had chosen to side with the religious groups and take up their cause during the July general elections.
PTI’s Dr. Arif Alvi meets #TLP leaders to seek support for presidential election— White Shadow (@Banjosahills) November 3, 2018
AUGUST 24, 2018
PTI supporters should join now as their puppet is unable to meet the demands of protestors. #AsiaBibi #KhadimRizvi pic.twitter.com/dkX6s3jRV5— Muhammad Imran (@mi1g08) November 1, 2018
Those who used the religion for election gains, what stance will they have now?— Democratic Insane (@e_hizb) October 31, 2018
#AasiaBibi #blasphemy pic.twitter.com/RtfTeuI3Wv
Some TLP supporters also tried to point out that the behaviour of their party and leaders was similar to that of the PTI supporters and leaders before the party came into power.
When pTi Terrorist will be arrested?@PTIofficial #RestoreKhadimHussainRizvi #PTI #TLPDharna #ImranKhan #NawazSharif #asifalizardari #AasiaBibiVerdict #HangAsiaAsPerLaw @AamirLiaquat @ARYNEWSOFFICIAL #Pakistanis #pakistanZindabaad #PakistanArmy#KhadimRizvi #FawadChaudhry pic.twitter.com/PFrJd1ZWxL— Defender (@defender14597) November 6, 2018
This is called true #Protest#tlp should learn from #PTI— Ali Ahmed Shah (@ShahKhaleefa) November 1, 2018
True #IslamicTeachings pic.twitter.com/18M1mwWeHh
We do not forgive. We do not forget.— Red Marker - پیرِ ٹویٹر (@RedMarkar) November 2, 2018
Thread of Pictures. When PTI use to do the similar which this #tlp is doing now a days. Shame on you #PTI pic.twitter.com/C1PrNXQmDj
#RestoreKhadimRizviAccount this is #PTI NOT #TLP #IStandWithKhadimRizvi #PAKvNZ #Begging pic.twitter.com/6992vHQ8vU— Shehzad Bilal Gohar (@ShehzadBilal167) November 4, 2018
Then, as Twitter suspended the account of TLP leader Khadim Hussain Rizvi for violating their rules, many saw it as a positive development. But supporters of the religious leader considered it as an attack on freedom of speech.
Thank You @Twitter - for suspending Khadim Hussain Rizvi's Twitter account! #PDS #TLP #KhadimRizvi pic.twitter.com/JUs0wzt1Ib— Zaheer Warraich 🇵🇰 (@zaheerwaraich84) November 5, 2018
This is non sense and sabotage of freedom of expression, the suspension of the account of @KhadimRizviReal . #RestoreKhadimRizviAccount#TLP— Shiraz Khan Babar (@ShirazCSE) November 5, 2018
Death of freedom of speech 75% mejority of the people of #Pakistan .@Twitter @Rizvi_1519 @Zem3284 @yasir_prof @Tabani_B #TLP #IStandWithKhadimRizvi @Aafiamovement @SaimaSadaf63 @NasirMinhas66 @LabbaikMediaPak @Zeeshan84255996 @RizviMedia92 pic.twitter.com/mz6wgZY2C5— Ahsan Rasheed (@AhsanR22) November 5, 2018
On the government's direction,closing account of Allama Khadim Hussain Rizvi under the PTA Administration,is nothing more than a nonsense.#TLP condemns it strongly!— Rizvi Media (@RizviMedia92) November 4, 2018
We tell the gov that these cowardly acts mean nothing to us! However the freedom of expression is sabotaged nicely pic.twitter.com/JWxPVEz2O4
Meanwhile, some tried to find humour in the whole situation.
All Pakistani monsters 👹are out to celebrate #Halloween since yesterday in the whole country.— Bushra Nasir Ahmed (@bushra_2010) November 1, 2018
Who says Halloween is not celebrated in 'Islamic Republic of Pakistan'?🤔#AsiaBibi#protest#TLP #protests pic.twitter.com/dr6Ja6fRrE
#Protest #Halloween in the US vs Halloween in #Pakistan #TLP celebrates Halloween with religious zeal— Mujeeb (@MujeebS9) November 1, 2018
That typical phrase “Mazhabi Josh o Jazbey Ke sath.” pic.twitter.com/Y5kZMsyGVs
MAD MaXX 2#TLP pic.twitter.com/7cV4klxK40— Sajjad Chandio (@SajjadC72585164) November 1, 2018
Out of all the images and videos of the mayhem that were circulating online, one image of a protestor holding a sword stood out the most and caught the attention of the Pakistani social media users.
When Pakistanis watch Game of Thrones. #TLP pic.twitter.com/g4MM77Vp3H— HQ (@Hassan_Qazi) November 1, 2018
The meme-generating factories in Pakistan then went into overdrive, engaging in photoshop battles.
Atleast this guy found his new job #protest #TLP #khadimhussainrizvi pic.twitter.com/XU9zCKHOK0— Da نish (@danishr_) November 2, 2018
I’m ded 😂😂😂 #TLP #Pakistan #protest pic.twitter.com/D9SMJdD3KH— Tasin (@tasinonfire) November 1, 2018
Meanwhile @ImranKhanPTI in #China 😆— Ahsaan ul Haq (@Ahsanul38833458) November 4, 2018
.#KhadimRizvi #PTI pic.twitter.com/CsW85lfLvP
Mullah of the Ring and the return of #KhadimRizvi part 3 surrender of nation 😂 pic.twitter.com/facixozepb— KHAN (@wkwazir33) November 4, 2018
India & Pakistan, Dividend by Borders & united by bigots.#protest #KhiAlerts #Pakistan #TLP #AasiaBibi pic.twitter.com/I1T7bCwSzs— Kashan Asghar (@kashanasghar) November 1, 2018
New Version Available:#GTA #TLP pic.twitter.com/Oz4pMkO7Dd— SialKoti 😎 (@iemTalHa) November 1, 2018
Molvi statue poised all over the world 🗺️🌍😎#ISPR #Pakistan #protests #KhadimRizvi #TLP #lslamicteachings #ImranKhan pic.twitter.com/6qAjgjDgKP— Mudasir Hussain Toorri (@mudasirtoori72) November 2, 2018
Round-1 ... FIGHT !!! 🤪🤜👊🤛⚔️#TLP #TLPDharna pic.twitter.com/8fnHusf7TR— Fahad Yousuf Khan (@fahadSEO) November 2, 2018
Grilling some barbecue today 🍗 🤣 #TLP pic.twitter.com/0kiFbwfCN9— Bisma Ali (@ibismaali) November 6, 2018
But the swordman's fifteen minutes of fame did not last, and the man was arrested.
Thakur ji has been arrested👇🏼. #KhadimHussainRizvi #KhadimRizvi pic.twitter.com/TtQ8nQvfey— Sαɾԃαɾ Mυԋαɱɱαԃ Dαɳιαʅ Aʅι (@danialgishkori) November 4, 2018
The protests by Pakistan's hardline groups also appeared to have garnered the attention of Dutch conservative leader Geert Wilders.
The same extremist Pakistani cleric who lead the shameful protest against the release of the brave christian #AsiaBibi issued a fatwa against me a few months ago.— Geert Wilders (@geertwilderspvv) November 2, 2018
This sponsor of hate, violence and terror should be jailed.
Retweet if you agree. #StopIslam pic.twitter.com/Tt0X6l1XV0
Asia Bibi's case
Asia Bibi, a Christian farm labourer, spent eight years on death row after she was accused by a group of women of making remarks blasphemous to Islam in 2009 following a fight that reportedly broke out over sharing a cup to drink water.
Asia Bibi denied the accusations, saying the women, along with a local cleric, had fabricated the charges. In 2010, a municipal court convicted her of committing blasphemy and sentenced her to death by hanging. Over the next few years, Asia Bibi’s case continued to polarise the country
Minorities Minister Shahbaz Bhatti and former Punjab governor Salman Taseer were assassinated in 2011 for defending Asia Bibi and advocating for reforms in Pakistan’s blasphemy laws.
I was under huge pressure sure 2 cow down b4 rightest pressure on blasphemy.Refused. Even if I'm the last man standing— Salmaan Taseer (@SalmaanTaseer) December 31, 2010
Show ur spirit RT @xabeen: RT @DrAwab: RT @FiveRupees: Rally against blasphemy laws - #Karachi 15th jan http://on.fb.me/hXGLp0— Salmaan Taseer (@SalmaanTaseer) December 30, 2010
The murders had also silenced a segment of society who had been seeking amendments in the country's controversial blasphemy laws, especially regarding the punishment for making false accusations.
Most religious groups consider any debate around the blasphemy laws to be blasphemy itself.
Dozens of Pakistanis - including many minority Christians or members of the Ahmadi faith - have been sentenced to death for blasphemy in the past decade, though no one has been executed.
Rights groups say the blasphemy law is exploited by religious extremists as well as ordinary Pakistanis to settle personal scores.
Taseer’s assassin, his bodyguard Mumtaz Qadri, was executed in 2016, but the execution turned him into a martyr.
Mumtaz Qadri was executed in 2016. Here are some pictures from his funeral. Look at the crowds full of his admirers. These people think of Qadri as a hero for assassinating the governor who opposed #AasiaBibi’s death sentence for blasphemy. Look at these crowds. /3 pic.twitter.com/cXcSYEqecq— Ali A. Rizvi (@aliamjadrizvi) October 31, 2018
Qadri’s supporters dedicated a shrine to him, and his actions inspired the foundation of the TLP party. But the demonstrations were downplayed in the Pakistani media.
No action was taken against the demonstrators who in some instances were seen hurling abuses at the powerful Pakistani military, an offense that rarely goes unpunished otherwise.
These Mullah's throwing shoes at helicopters!!— Aqib Mughal (@aqibmughal89) March 29, 2016
I'm almost done with my life.. #Irony pic.twitter.com/W89Oxx3FVK
The rise of TLP
The TLP had rode to prominence in November 2017 when the group staged a sit-in accusing the then law minister Zahid Hamid of blasphemy against Islam. They demanded the minister's dismissal and arrest over an attempt to make a small change in wording to an electoral law changing a religious oath to a simple declaration.
The religious party said the amendment in the law amounted to blasphemy.
Private TV stations were ordered off the air, with only state-run television broadcasting. Mobile phone coverage was also blocked in many areas.
Following the federal government's call for the Pakistan Army's help in clearing the sit-in, Chief of Army Staff General Qamar Javed Bajwah called on the civilian government to end the protest while “avoiding violence from both sides”.
COAS telephoned PM.Suggested to handle Isb Dharna peacefully avoiding violence from both sides as it is not in national interest & cohesion.— Maj Gen Asif Ghafoor (@OfficialDGISPR) November 25, 2017
The protests eventually ended after the then PML-N government struck a deal with the TLP that also saw the law minister resign from his post.
Those arrested for causing destruction of property during the protests were also later released on court's orders.
Army distributed money among #KhadimRizvi followers during previous govt, saying: “Aren’t we on your side?” It now says “don’t drag us into this”. #Pakistan #AsiaBibiVerdict— Bashir Ahmad Gwakh (@bashirgwakh) November 2, 2018
تمہیں یاد ہو کہ نہ یاد ہو pic.twitter.com/sTaYythI9f
Upon their release, some of the protesters were also handed cash that was distributed by the military, according to a video in which a general, who is seen handing out envelopes, can be heard telling the protestors, "Aren't we one of you?"